martechoutlook

This article is part of Martech Outlook's Innovation Insights series featuring expert contributions nominated by our subscribers and reviewed by our editorial team.

Innovation Needs Bashers: Why We Can't Leave Young People Behind

Daniel Reid, Founder and CEO , Steady Stream

Creative Development Advocate

Editor’s Note: For marketing agency owners and industry executives, artificial intelligence presents a growing responsibility to preserve the learning opportunities that develop future creative professionals. Investing efficiency gains in mentorship, meaningful assignments and hands-on experience can help agencies cultivate independent thinking, strengthen emerging talent and sustain the human judgment essential to lasting innovation.

Across the marketing industry, work that used to take a week now takes an afternoon.

Content calendars. First drafts. Campaign reports. Marketing plans. Keyword research. Emails. AI now handles much of it and handles it well. Clients get more for less. Agency margins look healthier than they have in years.

But that efficiency isn't free. Young people are paying for it.

This isn’t a shocking statement. This is something we all know. But it’s our responsibility as marketers to do something about it.

I was a terrible writer

I initially went into journalism because I wanted to change the world.

I grew up on punk zines: photocopied, stapled, passed hand to hand at shows. The people who made them were activists and they weren't waiting for anyone's permission. I wanted to be part of that.

There was one problem. I couldn't write.

I had a math and science brain. I loved that a problem could have a single right answer and that you could work your way to it, step by step. There's a comfort in that. Writing offered no such comfort. A blank page had a thousand possible answers and I froze in front of all of them. Words didn't flow for me. I had to drag them out, one at a time.

Around then I read Kurt Vonnegut's Timequake and one idea in it has stayed with me ever since. Vonnegut divided writers into two camps. Swoopers race through a messy draft, then circle back to fix it. Bashers grind forward sentence by sentence and refuse to move on until each one is right.

I knew instantly which one I was. I was a basher and a slow one. Every paragraph was hard work. Vonnegut counted himself a basher too and that gave me a strange kind of hope. Maybe slow wasn't the same as hopeless.

So I gave myself a reason to practise. I created my own comedy news website, inspired by The Onion. I spent countless hours writing a few dozen articles. None of it came easily. I taught myself how to write a lede, how to build a story, how to connect ideas and build towards a conclusion. But somewhere in that slow, stubborn work, something happened. My weakness became a strength.

The shortcut

Now picture a young person facing that same blank page today.

They don't have to bash through it. They don't have to fill scrap paper or sit with a bad draft until it gets better. An AI tool will hand them something polished in seconds. It feels good to be able to ascribe your name to something much better than you are capable of producing. But it's a shortcut and shortcuts skip the part where you grow.

Experienced professionals face a different temptation. The tedious work we once handed to juniors, the very work that trained many of us, now gets done without them. Why hire a beginner to write first drafts when a tool does it in seconds for a fraction of the cost (and, admittedly, offers better results)?

The first rung of the ladder hasn't just moved for young people: it's been sawed off.

Young people lose the struggle that builds skill. Our industry loses the pipeline that builds its future. And somewhere, a kid with a math brain and a stack of zines decides this career isn't for them.
  • The first rung of the ladder hasn't just moved for young people: it's been sawed off.


An industry that already knows the answer

At Steady Stream, we work exclusively with financial advisors, wealth managers and insurance advisors. They understand this problem better than most. Their industry has been facing its own succession challenge for years: advisors nearing retirement, practices with no one ready to serve clients past the next 10 years.

Their solution? They think about financial advisor succession early. They bring in junior advisors. They mentor them, share clients with them and build the next generation while they’re still relatively young.

Marketing agencies need the same thinking. If AI has handed agency owners massive savings, I don't believe those savings are entirely ours to keep. Some of that money and some of that time, should go back into the young people who would have filled those junior seats.

What I'm doing about it

We’re still a relatively small agency, so our ability to influence the industry is limited. But we can give more work to young people. We can give them a reason to build, test, think, learn, struggle and try. And we can give them the time, feedback and responsibility to get better at it.

Part of that means giving them room to develop their own ideas. Let them take a first attempt somewhere, explain their choices and work through the feedback. Give them a project they can take ownership of, where their judgment matters and they have to decide what to do next.

When you build something of your own, you can’t skip the hard parts. You have to decide what’s worth making, figure out how to make it and keep going when the first version falls short. You become your own critic, the one who looks at the work and says it isn’t good enough yet. You learn when to ask for help, when to rethink an idea and when to trust your instincts. And you start chasing your own inspiration, instead of waiting for someone to give you permission.

Those are skills you develop through practice. Giving someone the chance to do that work is one small, practical contribution we can make.

A request to other owners

If you own an agency, I'd ask you to do the same. Take one person. Give them your time, a real project to work on and the encouragement to go out and learn their own lessons.

The savings AI creates will go somewhere. They can disappear into our margins. Or they can become someone's first client, first paycheque, first taste of building something of their own.

Innovation can't lose the spirit of humanity. It's on us to make sure it doesn't.

MORE FROM INNOVATION INSIGHTS

Can AI Make Sales More Human Again?
Humantic AI
Amarpreet Kalkat, Founder & CEO
Building Smarter Sales Systems with Strategic AI
Alecci Media and co-founder of AI Boss Brainz
Kim Mylls, Director of Client Sales Strategy

EXPLORE OUR KNOWLEDGE NETWORK



The articles from these contributors are based on their personal expertise and viewpoints, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of their employers or affiliated organizations.