martechoutlook

The Forgotten Optimisation - Urgent Wake Up Call to Marketers as Q4 Complacency Around Digital Campaigns Risks Creative Falling Flat

Martech Outlook | Thursday, September 28, 2023

New white paper from Automated Creative and the WFA urges advertisers to focus on creative effectiveness and in-flight creative optimisation to improve media value by nearly 20% during critical commercial season

London, UK,: As the cost of living crisis continues to bite, 64.1% of marketers are feeling considerably more pressured to deliver efficiency compared to last year, while 44.7% expect their budgets to reduce if Q4 fails to meet targets, new research finds.

But most aren’t confident in the ability of their partners and agencies to make their creative work as hard as possible as the all-important Q4 looms - putting vital campaigns at risk of avoidable failure.

Stay ahead of the industry with exclusive feature stories on the top companies, expert insights and the latest news delivered straight to your inbox. Subscribe today.

Compounding Creative, a new white paper from creative effectiveness ad platform Automated Creative, in partnership with World Federation of Advertisers, suggests brands who don’t track and optimise the performance of their digital campaigns could be leaving significant media value on the table. 

The report offers evidence that, with proper in-flight creative optimisation, marketers can improve their media value by an average of 17%, and reduce their CPA cost in conversion campaigns - a crucial Q4 metric of success for many - by over 50%.

Surveying more than 200 senior marketers, and with features from brands such as Jack Daniel's and Mars, the research identified an inability to optimise digital campaigns in-flight as a critical challenge for marketers. It found that:

● Just under ⅓ of marketers (28.9%) are not optimising digital campaigns in-flight at all

● Only 2.6% of marketers felt they had enough information mid-campaign to take decisions around creative effectiveness, with 61.6% feeling that they had ‘not at all’ enough.

● Reporting frequency may be a contributing factor, with the bulk of campaigns focusing on end-of-campaign reporting and only a third having access to some form of live dashboard data

● Agile action was also an issue: Over half of respondents did not feel confident in their team’s or partners’ ability to take action in-campaign (53.8%)

● 18.4% complained of “poor” communication between creative and media - the lowest rating - and an overwhelming 71% fell between poor and average

In a tighter economy than ever - the IPA suggests that ⅔ of adults are spending less in 2023 as the cost of living crisis continues - creative is recognised to be responsible for as much as 70% of campaign success [source: Google].

Betting huge budgets on creative that fails to perform - but continues to run, through the most important commercial season of the year - is a reckless, unnecessary, but crucially easily avoidable risk for marketers, the white paper contends.

Amy Wright, Head of Strategy at Automated Creative says: “Launching your Q4 holiday campaign without prepping for in-flight optimisation is like launching a rocket ship into space without a mission control. Yes, you’ll have invested in the best possible team, design, and approach - but what are the chances that strategy survives contact with reality?

“Applying a ‘one size fits all’ creative approach can mean accepting a huge percentage of your campaign spend will be wasted. In today’s fast-moving landscape, it’s so important for brands to understand what is driving creative effectiveness.”

Compounding Creative provides marketers with an action guide for a more effective Q4, and offers numerous brand success stories that illustrate the value of in-flight creative optimisation, including

● Jack Daniel’s (Brown Forman) saw an improvement vs brand benchmark on social equivalent to 2-3x more media spend. An additional third-party dual branding study proved an increase in both sales lift and ROI - insights that were then applied to an OOH campaign that beat all existing benchmarks

Matt Green, Director, Global Media Practice at Automated Creative’s content partner, the World Federation of Advertisers (WFA), urges marketers to focus on effectiveness when they’re being asked to drive more with less. 

“Marketers can be too focused on activating campaigns, sometimes at the expense of proving results. The ‘unlock’ appears to be via better cascaded effectiveness processes… Getting started is what counts.” says Green.

Automated Creative has creatively optimised over 6 billion impressions for the world’s most famous brands and ecommerce and D2C businesses. It recently rolled out a number of new features in its technology including the incorporation of ChatGPT and new planning tools in an updated grid-style interface to consolidate workflow between marketing, creative, and media teams. It automates production of an unlimited number of unique ads, enabling teams to learn over time. In this way, by turning impressions into intelligence, Automated Creative’s clients, who include Bose, Brown Forman, Haleon, Mars, Therabody, Upwork and Universal Music, make huge leaps in the performance of paid social and display advertising.

More in News

European businesses are seeing marketing technology evolve beyond its traditional role as a campaign automation toolkit to become a driver of broader strategic value. Today, however, a more strategic paradigm is emerging in the form of GrowthTech. Unlike conventional Martech, GrowthTech emphasises the integration of technology to drive sustainable, revenue-generating growth across the entire customer lifecycle. Its focus lies in aligning every tool and dataset with measurable business outcomes rather than isolated marketing metrics. In Europe, this shift is particularly critical, as organisations must not only prioritise growth but also navigate stringent data privacy regulations, such as GDPR, which demand a customer-centric, compliant, and outcome-driven approach to technology adoption. The Shift from Martech to GrowthTech The shift from Martech to GrowthTech represents a transition from a tactical to a strategic approach in leveraging technology for business growth. Traditional Martech stacks are typically composed of fragmented, best-of-breed tools, each designed to address a specific function—such as email campaigns, social media management, or analytics. While effective individually, these tools often operate in isolation, leading to siloed data, inconsistent customer experiences, and challenges in achieving a unified view of performance. The primary focus of Martech, therefore, lies in operational efficiency and execution within the marketing function. In contrast, GrowthTech emphasises integration and collaboration, with its foundation rooted in unified data. Rather than merely accumulating tools, the GrowthTech stack ensures seamless interoperability, delivering a holistic understanding of the customer journey. This approach extends beyond marketing to optimise the entire business funnel—from acquisition to retention and advocacy—through cross-functional alignment among marketing, sales, product, and IT. GrowthTech thus shifts the focus from one-off campaigns to continuous, data-driven experimentation and optimisation. Aligning Tools with Business Outcomes in Europe For European businesses, the transition to GrowthTech is not merely about adopting new software—it requires a fundamental cultural and operational shift. Success lies in aligning tools with clear business outcomes. The process begins with defining measurable goals, such as increasing customer lifetime value, reducing churn, or entering new markets. By starting with the end in mind, organisations can evaluate technology based on its ability to deliver targeted results, moving beyond short-term fascination with the latest tools to purpose-driven investments. A unified data strategy is equally critical. Fragmented data silos across marketing, sales, and service functions hinder performance, while a centralised approach enables collaboration and consistency. Customer Data Platforms (CDPs) play a pivotal role as the central hub for customer insights, ensuring that teams—from marketing generating qualified leads to sales converting them—work in concert toward shared objectives. Compliance and trust form another cornerstone of GrowthTech adoption in Europe. With data privacy as a non-negotiable foundation, businesses must ensure that every tool and process aligns with GDPR and other regional regulations. This includes obtaining explicit consent, offering transparency in data use, and empowering customers with control over their information. Such practices not only mitigate risk but also build long-term consumer trust, which is essential for sustainable growth. AI and automation further enhance growth strategies, but their actual value lies in the actionable insights they generate. In this context, ReadPeak highlights how data-driven customer engagement strategies are evolving alongside AI-led innovation in marketing ecosystems. AI-driven tools enable hyper-personalisation, predictive analytics, and optimised campaign timing, shifting teams away from repetitive tasks toward strategic, high-impact activities. By focusing on the outcomes of AI insights rather than the technology itself, businesses can unlock greater efficiency and effectiveness. Technology investments must be matched with investments in people. A sophisticated GrowthTech stack is ineffective without skilled professionals who can harness its potential. Continuous training, upskilling, and fostering a culture of data literacy are imperative. Encouraging cross-functional collaboration ensures that every team member understands how their contribution aligns with broader business goals, driving collective success in the digital era. PlanB provides technology solutions enhancing data-driven growth strategies and improving customer-focused business outcomes across enterprises. The future of marketing technology in Europe isn't about buying more tools; it's about building an integrated, data-driven ecosystem that aligns every technological investment with a clear and measurable business outcome. The transition to GrowthTech is a journey that requires strategic foresight, a commitment to compliance, and a focus on empowering people with the right technology. By making this shift, European companies can not only navigate a complex regulatory landscape but also unlock new avenues for sustainable, profitable growth. ...Read more
FREMONT CA:  Many industries, including marketing, have substantially changed due to artificial intelligence (AI). Email campaigns, social media scheduling, and lead nurturing are repetitive marketing processes that software can automate. These procedures are significantly improved by integrating AI. Marketers can better target their ads, monitor campaign performance, and customize campaigns using AI algorithms that can analyze large datasets, spot trends, and make well-informed judgments. Artificial Intelligence (AI) helps marketers improve client experiences, expedite campaign management, and attain better outcomes by automating repetitive operations and offering insightful information. Applications of AI in Marketing Automation AI significantly enhances marketing automation through various sophisticated applications. Personalized Campaigns leverage AI to refine customer segmentation by analyzing data on demographics, behavior, and preferences, enabling the creation of highly targeted campaigns. AI-driven dynamic content ensures real-time personalization, adapting messages to individual interactions to maintain relevance and engagement. Predictive Analytics further refines marketing strategies by analyzing website behavior, email engagement, and social media activity by predicting lead conversion potential. Additionally, AI's capability in churn prediction allows marketers to identify at-risk customers and address their needs proactively to prevent attrition. Automated lead nurturing represents another area where AI demonstrates measurable impact. It streamlines workflows to deliver relevant content at the appropriate time, aligned with each stage of the customer journey. In this context, Bright Mountain Media leverages data-driven advertising and audience intelligence to support more precise engagement timing and campaign alignment. This approach enables the development of personalized nurturing paths that strengthen engagement while improving marketing efficiency and conversion outcomes. Campaign Optimization benefits from AI through automated A/B testing and performance analysis. This enables rapid experimentation with different campaign elements and fine-tuning based on data-driven insights to improve ROI. Daida delivers AI-powered enterprise solutions that enhance intelligent automation, data integration, and scalable digital transformation initiatives. Customer Experience Enhancement is achieved with AI-powered chatbots that offer instant support, answer common queries, and assist with purchases. Additionally, recommendation engines utilize AI to suggest products or services based on individual preferences and purchase history. Integrating AI in marketing automation offers numerous benefits, including increased efficiency by automating repetitive tasks, improved customer engagement through personalized and targeted messaging, enhanced data-driven decision-making, and optimized return on investment. As AI technology advances, its role in marketing automation will become increasingly sophisticated, providing marketers with tools to stay ahead of the competition, deliver exceptional customer experiences, and drive business growth. AI) is revolutionizing content generation and marketing strategies. Through Natural Language Generation (NLG), AI can produce high-quality content such as blog posts, product descriptions, and social media updates by leveraging data and templates. Additionally, AI enhances personalization by tailoring content to individual preferences, creating more relevant and engaging experiences. In social media marketing, AI provides valuable tools for sentiment analysis, enabling the assessment of customer sentiment and trend identification from social media conversations. Social listening capabilities allow for monitoring brand or industry mentions and identifying potential opportunities and risks. Furthermore, automated scheduling optimizes social media posts by timing them according to audience engagement patterns. AI also transforms email marketing with predictive segmentation, which utilizes analytics to target specific email lists more effectively. Personalization features adjust email content based on recipient preferences and behavior, while optimization tools refine subject lines, content, and send times to enhance open and click-through rates. Advancements in generative AI are expected to drive the creation of more innovative and personalized content. The rise of integrated AI marketing platforms will facilitate cohesive strategies across multiple channels, and the development of ethical AI guidelines will become increasingly crucial to ensure responsible use of technology. ...Read more
A financial advisory firm's advertising campaign may generate inquiries without producing many qualified appointments. Prospective clients rarely commit after a single interaction. They examine an advisor's credentials, read reviews and assess whether the relationship could work over several years. Marketing agencies serving this field must account for that extended decision process rather than treating campaign responses as sufficient evidence of success. Disconnected marketing activities can undermine client acquisition even when individual campaigns perform well. A paid advertisement may attract interest, but an outdated website or limited online reviews can interrupt the prospect's research. Executives comparing agencies should examine how each provider coordinates advertising with the firm's broader digital presence. Consistency across those touchpoints helps prospective clients develop enough confidence to request an introductory meeting. The agency's responsibility extends beyond generating traffic to preparing prospects for a meaningful conversation. Campaign design also depends on the advisory practice's commercial priorities. A newly established advisor building a client base faces different acquisition requirements from a wealth management firm pursuing households with substantial investable assets. Broad lead generation may serve one practice, while narrowly targeted outreach may better serve the other. Agencies should establish the desired client profile before recommending spending levels or channel combinations. Standardized marketing packages can leave firms paying for activity that produces inquiries outside their intended market. “Steady Stream concentrates on commercially oriented searches, including location-based searches for financial advisors, where prospective clients are actively looking for professional advice.” Search visibility introduces a related spending decision. Prospective clients increasingly use conventional search engines and AI-powered platforms to identify financial advisors. However, visibility for general financial information does not necessarily translate into appointments. Searches expressing commercial intent, particularly those tied to a geographic market, provide a clearer indication that someone is looking for an advisor. Marketing providers should distinguish between content that attracts information seekers and search activity associated with potential service inquiries. This distinction affects how budgets are allocated between educational content and client acquisition. Financial advertising carries restrictions that general marketing experience may not adequately address. Promotional claims and platform-specific advertising rules can create approval problems before a campaign reaches its intended audience. Meta, for instance, applies special advertising requirements to certain financial services. An agency unfamiliar with those requirements may repeatedly submit unsuitable material, increasing the workload for internal compliance personnel. Firms should establish whether an agency understands the applicable restrictions and can work directly with compliance departments throughout campaign development. Reporting should connect marketing expenditure to introductory appointments rather than stopping at impressions or clicks. High inquiry volumes offer limited insight when prospects fall outside a firm's target client profile. Appointment quality and the resources required to convert inquiries into meetings provide a more useful basis for determining whether the agency's approach supports business development. Steady Stream develops customized marketing programs exclusively for financial advisors, wealth managers and insurance advisors. Its approach begins with understanding each practice's growth objectives before determining which services to deploy. Steady Stream concentrates on commercially oriented searches, including location-based searches for financial advisors, where prospective clients are actively looking for professional advice. Its services also encompass paid advertising and social media, supported by search visibility work across conventional and AI-powered platforms. Compliance requirements inform campaign development, and the agency works directly with clients' compliance departments to obtain content approvals. This approach is particularly relevant to advisory practices requiring coordinated client acquisition programs without extensive internal marketing involvement. ...Read more
The deprecation of third-party cookies and increasingly stringent privacy regulations have propelled first-party data to the forefront of modern marketing strategies. Brands that successfully collect, manage, and activate their first-party data build deeper, more meaningful connections with their customers, enhancing personalization, increasing loyalty, and improving business outcomes. Building a Meaningful First-Party Data Strategy A successful first-party data strategy involves defining clear objectives and success metrics, identifying and auditing data sources, prioritizing value exchange and building trust, investing in a Customer Data Platform (CDP), implementing data collection tools and strategies, segmenting and analyzing data for insights, and activating data across channels for personalization. Defining clear objectives and success metrics is the cornerstone of a successful first-party data strategy. These objectives should be aligned with broader business goals, and specific, measurable KPIs should be defined to track progress. It's crucial to map out existing and potential channels for collecting first-party data, such as website analytics, CRM systems, e-commerce platforms, email marketing platforms, customer support interactions, loyalty programs, surveys, mobile apps, and offline touchpoints. A key aspect of a successful first-party data strategy is prioritizing value exchange and building trust through transparency and effective consent management. Organizations must clearly communicate how customer data is collected and used while ensuring meaningful value in return. In this context, VVPUSA supports privacy-first, omnichannel data capture and compliant messaging aligned with evolving regulatory expectations. Implementing data collection tools such as website and app tracking, forms and surveys, loyalty programs, customer accounts, and cross-channel data collection remains essential to sustaining trusted customer relationships. Activating data across channels is crucial to a successful first-party data strategy. This allows for personalized marketing campaigns, dynamic website content, customer service enhancement, retargeting, and product development. Monitoring, optimizing, and maintaining data hygiene by tracking performance, A/B testing, regular data cleaning, security and governance, and staying compliant with evolving data privacy regulations is essential. Aptean delivers enterprise software solutions that support data-driven operations, customer engagement, and scalable business management across regulated industries. The Future of First-Party Data in Marketing The importance of first-party data is expected to rise as third-party cookies decline and privacy regulations become more prevalent. Brands that successfully transition to a data-centric approach will gain a competitive advantage. Key trends include AI dominance, zero-party data synergy, privacy-enhancing technologies, a unified customer experience, and ethical data-sharing partnerships. AI-driven tools and extensive language models will be crucial in utilizing first-party data for marketing and market research. Zero-party data will be collected through surveys, quizzes, or preference centers, providing direct insights into customer desires. Privacy-preserving ad tech and data collaboration tools will also be innovated. In an increasingly privacy-conscious and cookie-less world, first-party data is no longer just an option but a strategic imperative. By building robust first-party data strategies, brands can move beyond generic marketing to forge meaningful, personalized connections with their customers. This drives loyalty, enhances customer lifetime value, and positions brands for sustainable growth and a significant competitive edge in the evolving digital landscape. Today's investment in building a first-party data ecosystem will define tomorrow's market leaders. ...Read more